16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza vs Whole 18" Cheese Pizza
Papa John's vs Costco Food Court · calories, protein, price & value compared
On overall value, Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza wins — value score 89 vs 69.
For the most protein per dollar, go Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza (24.0g vs 3.8g per $).
Pure protein: Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza has more (239g vs 90g).
Lighter option: Papa John's 16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza (2,480 vs 4,540 cal).
16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza
Calories2,480
Total Fat80 g
Saturated Fat36 g
Sodium5,970 mg
Total Carbs340 g
Fiber15 g
Sugars47 g
Protein90 g
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza
Calories4,540
Total Fat176 g
Saturated Fat99 g
Sodium10,440 mg
Total Carbs478 g
Fiber44 g
Sugars30 g
Protein239 g
| Metric | 16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza | Whole 18" Cheese Pizza |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $23.89 | $9.95 ✓ |
| Calories | 2,480 | 4,540 |
| Protein | 90g | 239g ✓ |
| Carbs | 340g | 478g |
| Fat | 80g | 176g |
| Protein / $ | 3.8g | 24.0g ✓ |
| Calories / $ | 104 | 456 ✓ |
| Protein / 100 cal | 3.6g | 5.3g ✓ |
| Health score | 72 | 74 ✓ |
| Value score | 69 | 89 ✓ |
Price is the real national figure we collect; value score blends protein-per-dollar (45%), calories-per-dollar (15%) and nutrition quality (40%). Methodology →