16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza — Papa John's
Pizza
Nutrition Facts
Value score blends protein-per-dollar (45%), calories-per-dollar (15%) and nutrition quality (40%) against every priced item we track. How it’s calculated →
Is the 16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza a good deal?
At a typical $23.89, the 16 Inch New York Style Garden Fresh Pizza at Papa John's gives you 2,480 calories and 90g of protein — 3.8g of protein and 104 calories for every dollar you spend. That earns it a value score of 69/100, which ranks it #63 of the 96 pizza items we've priced across every chain (the typical pizza item returns about 4.1g of protein per dollar).
Where it stands out: a high absolute protein load (90g); 15g of fiber. Worth noting, though — sodium runs high (5,970mg), and it carries a lot of sugar (47g). If you want more for your money in the same category, Cheese Pizza (Slice) at Costco Food Court scores higher (91/100 value, $1.99).
Price by metro
| Metro | Price | Protein / $ | Cal / $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Houston | $21.99 | 4.1g | 113 |
| Miami | $23.49 | 3.8g | 106 |
| Minneapolis | $23.50 | 3.8g | 106 |
| Atlanta | $23.89 | 3.8g | 104 |
| Los Angeles | $23.99 | 3.8g | 103 |
| Denver | $28.99 | 3.1g | 86 |
| Chicago | $29.99 | 3.0g | 83 |