12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza vs Pepperoni Pizza (Slice)
Papa John's vs Costco Food Court · calories, protein, price & value compared
On overall value, Costco Food Court Pepperoni Pizza (Slice) wins — value score 89 vs 68.
For the most protein per dollar, go Costco Food Court Pepperoni Pizza (Slice) (16.6g vs 3.8g per $).
Pure protein: Papa John's 12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza has more (75g vs 33g).
Lighter option: Costco Food Court Pepperoni Pizza (Slice) (710 vs 1,560 cal).
12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Calories1,560
Total Fat59 g
Saturated Fat24 g
Sodium5,600 mg
Total Carbs180 g
Fiber8 g
Sugars22 g
Protein75 g
Pepperoni Pizza (Slice)
Calories710
Total Fat28 g
Saturated Fat13 g
Sodium1,767 mg
Total Carbs77 g
Fiber6 g
Sugars5 g
Protein33 g
| Metric | 12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | Pepperoni Pizza (Slice) |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $19.50 | $1.99 ✓ |
| Calories | 1,560 | 710 |
| Protein | 75g ✓ | 33g |
| Carbs | 180g | 77g |
| Fat | 59g | 28g |
| Protein / $ | 3.8g | 16.6g ✓ |
| Calories / $ | 80 | 357 ✓ |
| Protein / 100 cal | 4.8g ✓ | 4.6g |
| Health score | 74 | 74 |
| Value score | 68 | 89 ✓ |
Price is the real national figure we collect; value score blends protein-per-dollar (45%), calories-per-dollar (15%) and nutrition quality (40%). Methodology →
More Pizza matchups
12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza vs Cheese Pizza (Slice)
Papa John's vs Costco Food Court
12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza vs Combo Pizza (Slice)
Papa John's vs Costco Food Court
12 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza vs Whole 18" Cheese Pizza
Papa John's vs Costco Food Court