Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 16 Inch New York Style Super Hawaiian Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's · calories, protein, price & value compared
On overall value, Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza wins — value score 89 vs 81.
For the most protein per dollar, go Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza (24.0g vs 5.4g per $).
Pure protein: Costco Food Court Whole 18" Cheese Pizza has more (239g vs 130g).
Lighter option: Papa John's 16 Inch New York Style Super Hawaiian Pizza (2,960 vs 4,540 cal).
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza
Calories4,540
Total Fat176 g
Saturated Fat99 g
Sodium10,440 mg
Total Carbs478 g
Fiber44 g
Sugars30 g
Protein239 g
16 Inch New York Style Super Hawaiian Pizza
Calories2,960
Total Fat111 g
Saturated Fat50 g
Sodium8,010 mg
Total Carbs350 g
Fiber14 g
Sugars55 g
Protein130 g
| Metric | Whole 18" Cheese Pizza | 16 Inch New York Style Super Hawaiian Pizza |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $9.95 ✓ | $23.89 |
| Calories | 4,540 | 2,960 |
| Protein | 239g ✓ | 130g |
| Carbs | 478g | 350g |
| Fat | 176g | 111g |
| Protein / $ | 24.0g ✓ | 5.4g |
| Calories / $ | 456 ✓ | 124 |
| Protein / 100 cal | 5.3g ✓ | 4.4g |
| Health score | 74 ✓ | 72 |
| Value score | 89 ✓ | 81 |
Price is the real national figure we collect; value score blends protein-per-dollar (45%), calories-per-dollar (15%) and nutrition quality (40%). Methodology →
More Pizza matchups
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 16 Inch New York Style Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 14 Inch Original Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 14 Inch Original BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 14 Inch Original Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 16 Inch New York Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's
Whole 18" Cheese Pizza vs 16 Inch New York Style BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza
Costco Food Court vs Papa John's